Navigating The Ethics Of Instagramming The Kids

Written by

Kate Maclean

10:00 am
04/12/17

Photograph via Isabelle O’Connor

National Geographic photographers have a guiding principle by which they photograph: never manipulate the subjects for a shot. Their mission is to capture the wild of life and interfering with a scene would by virtue negate its wildness. They would no more leave a gazelle tied to a tree to entice a grey wolf, than fix a bonnet to a baby elephant (as adorable as the latter would be). They let the wild speak for itself, unadulterated.

American living rooms and the children that fill them are many a mile from the Mongolian steppe and the gazelle that leaps through. But, parents document their children with the same vigor and devotion as the photographer documents the leaping mammal and much of it ends up on social media.

It is estimated that parents will post an average of 1000 pictures of their child before that child reaches five years old. According to the Pew Research Center, 75% of parents are on social media and 25% of that number is on Instagram. In this endlessly scrolling world, might parents borrow the heart of the guiding Nat Geo principle when it concerns ‘gramming their kids?

American children are not living in a wild habitat. They live in the habitat that their parents—the photographers—have created for them. Parents, by virtue of their job, are constantly manipulating this habitat. They buy the clothes, wipe faces, brush hair. Parents are their child’s schedulers, their wardrobe, their hair and makeup, their secretaries, bodyguards, advocates, and lobbyists. Most notably in the iPhone Age they are the paparazzi, the documentarians; constantly thrusting the smooth, rectangular extensions of their hands into daily life.

Unlike with the wildlife photographer, there is no clear line on Instagram to distinguish when parental manipulation of the subject’s behavior goes too far.

Where does the line lie between coaxing a baby to smile for the camera and placing that same blinking infant in the grass in the spoon of a dozing unicorn with daisies strewn artfully around the pair? She didn’t just fall asleep like that. The world isn’t that perfectly magical.

The world is that accidentally magical. Parents witness it everyday in their kids—or nearly every day depending on sleep and sugar levels. And yet, the allure of setting and sharing the perfect photo is consuming. Imagine an impossibly clean living room, pillows fluffed, fresh flowers smiling. A cookie sits on the coffee table waiting to entice the wild animal as she walks through and into the apple-d frame of the iPhone. A 2015 study by Joseph Grenny and David Maxfield found that 79% of respondents have witnessed a parent undermine their experience in their child’s life to get the “perfect post”. Maxfield writes, “If our attention is on an invisible audience rather than the present moment, we are disconnected. Our devices are beginning to control our attention and motivations in ways we may not even realize.”

Users will agree in hackneyed-unison that Instagram is an excellent way to keep up with friends. Instagram is also a forum to bounce ideas, a marketplace to create and sell, an avenue for friendship, a bosom for activism. Most infamously, Instagram has become a way to show just how wonderful, inspiring, and orderly the ‘grammer’s life is. The platform is entirely visual. The posted photo is a half second to say, “Look how pretty, now listen to me!” It is more difficult to successfully impart: My house is a mess and the kid is throwing a tantrum, but I have some worthy things to say, just give me a chance!

The Grenny study also found that 58% of respondents report that getting a picture perfect for a post has prevented them from enjoying life experiences. The procession of Instagram perfection creates a self-sustaining cycle. The more saturated it becomes of admirably curated kids, the more rare the photo of an unadulterated childhood a-mess and askew.

Instagram itself offers few guidelines to navigate this ethical balance. They keep it simple in their Tips for Parents page (no nudity, no child pornography) leaving parents to navigate the balance.

How then can parents post photos of their children while respecting the sanctity of childhood and parenthood? Parents could do well to create personal guidelines in the vein of National Geographic. Grenny and Maxfield offer recommendations for social media use as a whole that could easily be adapted for Instagram moms and dads:

Look at yourself
If other adults were in the room, what would they think about your setting up of the shot?

Limit your postings
Consider limiting Instagram use to once a day, thereby removing the specter of posting and scrolling from the rest of your day.

Snap, look, and listen
Take the photo and then get back to enjoying their childhood.

At times, Instagram is an endless procession of beautiful clothes, enviable vacations, and well-behaved children. But, to what expense does that come to the lives outside the phone? Adam Alter warns last month in the New York Times, “We’ve become obsessed with how many ‘likes’ our Instagram photos are getting instead of where we are walking and whom we are talking to.” If parents were to heed this warning and the conclusions of the Grenny study, they may find themselves emulating their Nat Geo counterparts; capturing their wild animals living their wild life.

Leave a Comment

15 comments

Katie

This is so spot on! The culture of setting up the perfect shot in motherhood is crazy to me! I mean, I can barely take a decent family photo once a year! I love the thought about National Geographic photographers. These principles are exactly what we celebrate on our website.

Nikki

I gave up social media (both Instagram and Facebook) for lent, and I may not go back after Easter. I’m enjoying a more authentic experience with my child becasue I’m much more present, and not ever-alert for postable moments, asking my child to hold still and smile while I snap 20 shots and choose the perfect filter.

Alexandra

Some great suggestions but I feel the article is missing a discussion about the idea of not posting pictures of your child on social media period. And for those who can’t resist the temptation what about discussion around safety (ie. no geo tagging pics of your kids or pictures in front of their schools etc).

    Alia

    Really good point!! I made my acct private because I was starting to see an alarming number of parents freaking out because they’d discovered someone was stealing pictures of their kids and posting them on those creepy baby roleplay accounts.

    Elizabeth

    Yes. I clicked through on this article looking for just that angle.

    I try not to post photos of my toddler on social media. If I really can’t resist the temptation, I snap one where her face is not visible–either it’s obscured by a book or a hat, or she’s looking off to the side.

    I don’t need to create a digital identity for her.

Alia

People who set up “scenes” to perfectly pose their children in are so obviously unauthentic. One or two “set up” photos in your instagram feed may go unnoticed, but if you make it a regular habit, people will take notice. I think the only thing that can ruin an instagram feed more than faked photos is the rampant overuse of product placement. I love seeing shared moments that make me smile, laugh, or even inspire me. I don’t want to be bombarded with unnaturally perfect photos or advertisements for shampoo.

Carrie

I agree with Alexandra up there. Yes, lets be more mindful of the present moment and people we are with; however, where is the discussion of the ethics of publicly posting pictures of our children at all? We are creating a digital legacy for our children they have no control over. And how will this legacy serve or haunt them in the future? Not posting publicly isn’t just about safeguarding our children from potential predators, but giving them digital identity freedom. I ask this as a mom who indeed wants the entire world to know that she birthed the worlds cutest baby.

Rebecca

I wish more parents put more thought behind why and what they put online of their kids. After posting a few pictures in the first year of my daughter’s life, I decided to stop. Mostly because I realized her whole life is going to be online in ways I can’t even imagine, and I want her to be able to have control over what it looks like. Now I only post once in a blue moon and only of photos where you can’t see her face, like her hands drawing.

Sarah

I completely agree with Carrie and Alexandra’s comments above! I think the more apparent ethical question is around publicly sharing images of your children at all when they are not at an age to make an informed choice or understand the potential consequences. That to me would be a much more interesting discussion.

Patti

I may be a tad biased given that Kate’s my daughter-in-law, but her photos and captions on Instagram and Facebook have authentically earned her a following of over 27 thousand. Kate, you always think of your kids first when photographing and posting. I remember wanting to post a photo you took of Leland and Amelia in the bathtub and you cautioned me about nudity on FB. I did it anyway, didn’t get my FB (or Instagram??) hand slapped, and really, how cute is a baby’s tush!! You are the BEST mother, and I am the luckiest mother-in-law and nana… Terrific article!! Keep writing (of course, when the kids are sleeping…) ;-)

Lynn Donaldson

That’s right. I shoot and write for National Geographic Traveler, and I Instagram for Nat Geo Travel. (Though because I shoot professionally, I get overwhelmed logging onto Instagram and posting in my “free” time & have been lazy. I should keep it up, though. It’s surreal to post a pic and get 2,000K likes in under a minute…and thrilling to get over 150K within 24 hours.) We never, ever manipulate or remove anything…or even crop. We crop in-camera. We can ONLY post images we shot with cameras; no cell phone shots allowed. Also, we are never supposed to post more than one image per day and are encouraged to limit our tags to under 7, with 3-5 being optimal. I always roll my eyes when I see way too many hashtags on a post. One friend of mine puts 20-30+ on every image. Of her kids! I’ve got 3 gorgeous children under 10 but I leave them off Instagram for the most part.

    Nikki

    You should check out Stellashare! We created it for easy private photo sharing after the birth of our daughter. Stellashare.com

ALL MATERIAL © MOTHER LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. SITE DESIGNED BY JANE REACTION, DEVELOPED BY BRANDI BERNOSKIE