Oh, the things we wish we knew before we ever stepped into a toy store (or clicked over to Amazon)! The toys the kids begged for and promised to love forever were rarely the ones that got constant use, year after year. But the toys that proved their staying power? They are still here—scuffed and well-worn, but still in constant rotation. From blocks to beloved baby dolls to that one super-soft stuffy, we bring you a realistic round up of the toys that can grow with them—and that your kids will insist on growing up with. Click through the slideshow below to see our 30 toy box essentials.

For more no-fail entertainment for kids, check out these 40 children’s book titles that feature strong female characters. Plus, 70+ books that are considered the very best of 2018!